The Passionate Imperfection of a National Top 100 Courses List

I’m a lists guy. I have them everywhere. There’s my bucket list (which now requires a serious update). And there are the mundane day to day lists but talking great golf courses of Canada is anything but mundane. Sports lend themselves well to arguing greatness. I have friends that will argue every chance we get who are the best baseball and hockey players of all time. Comparing stats across generations creates apples to oranges arguments for some. Do we have the same issue when discussing great golf courses in Canada? There are modern designs versus historic or classic tracks. And unless you’re Robert Thompson it’s likely you have not played a significantly large number of courses on the list. I’ve played 11 of the SCOREGolf Top 100 and really need to step up my game here.

I love the fact that Grand Niagara made the list. My review of that course from earlier this year is woefully inadequate having played there two times since. The more I play it the more I love it; there are subtleties to the course which make it a tough test. And while it lacks the jaw dropping beauty of ocean or mountain courses, the conditioning is flawless. Then there’s the immaculate and value-winner Black Bear Ridge in Belleville. It’s a great course, but to see it at 100 only whets the appetite for me to get out and play others on the list. Humber Valley in Newfoundland was a pleasant surprise to be ranked so high. But it is breathtaking and backed up with one of the best layouts I’ve experienced. I didn’t love Bear Mountain’s Mountain course but feel it deserves top 100 rankings. Dakota Dunes deserves its spot on the list, maybe a higher ranking too.

Some courses will be disappointed to miss out. The marketing opportunity of being on the list is not insignificant. Stunning courses like The Lakes in Ben Eoin, Nova Scotia complement the stout top 10 courses also on Cape Breton Island, Cabot Links and Highlands Links. And while I could kick up a fuss and argue that The Lakes was robbed of a rightful place on this list, I see the imperfection of a national list of the top 100 courses. My advice, market yourself as #101 and play up the convenience of being so close to such great courses like Cabot Links and Highlands Links.

As for us players, let’s respectfully engage in the dialogue. Let’s share the omissions, question the courses which made it which are not as great as your favorite and then let’s do ourselves a favour and get out and play some of these gems…let’s make informed decisions.
I will pour myself a Triple Bogey, review the list again and later this week chime in on twitter using #SGTop100. As for the baseball and hockey players…that’s easy, it’s Ruth and Orr. Now the bigger question, will Cabot Cliffs break Cabot Links record for a debut high when the 2016 list comes out?

 

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “The Passionate Imperfection of a National Top 100 Courses List

  1. Bear mountain in Victoria is stunning. Westmount is underrated. Beacon hall is overrated. Best course not to make the list is whirlpool or ambassador in Windsor.

    • Thanks ‘me’. I can’t disagree, Bear Mountain is stunning but its odd when the most picturesque hole is not part of the 18. Feels like a missed opportunity in the layout. I like it alot, just don’t love it. And thanks too for the feedback on other courses. Appreciate the heads up!

  2. Hey Mike,

    I’ve had the pleasure of playing 29 of the top 100 – 5 in the top 10 and as you know I’m a proud member of The Grand Niagara (#83). I think all these lists are very subjective and what one person thinks is a great course, might not resonate with someone else. I think the top 3 are bang on and I can’t wait to Cabot Cliffs opens in 2015.

    Hopefully we can knock off Le Geant, Le Diable and La Maitre in Mont Tremblant this fall – three amazing tracks I’ve played in the past.

    As we prepare our PEI trip next fall, I’m looking forward to knocking of Fox Harb’r off the list and if we can swing by NS for a Cabot Links, that would be good too 🙂

    Cheers,
    Andrew

    • Andrew, great seeing your course on the list. It’s justified. 29 is impressive and I’d love to see if/how we could knock off Fox Harb’r next fall!

      Cheers, MJ

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s