My PEI Course Ranking – After and Before

On September 4, in advance of my golf trip to PEI I shared this post  which outlined my top 10 list of PEI courses based on my research. Having played all 10 courses now, I am pleased to share my ‘after’ list. There are revisions, which is natural. But understand this list for what it is; a personal and subjective list of golf courses. Golf course beauty is clearly in the eye of the beholder, as I will share some sentiments from my playing partners who, in many cases, share differing opinions of these courses. But that is why I love lists; they provide fodder for debate and conversation. So with all that said, here is my Top 10 PEI Courses List, after the trip:

015

The amazing par 4 8th hole at Dundarave. This picture doesn’t do justice to its beauty.

10 – Anderson’s Creek – Perhaps a little unfair, as this course did suffer the most extensive winter kill of any of the other 9 we played. However, the layout was not as dynamic as others on the Island. I found the par 3’s drew too much on design with wide greens that lack depth. The creek is a prominent feature of the course and adds to the natural beauty and challenge of this course. Others had this 9th or 10th, which spoke more of the depth and diversity of courses than anything else.

9 – Stanhope – I don’t think I’ve ever loved something ranked 9th as much as I love this course. Relaxed and unique, this course draws extensively on strong dog legs. I did not prefer this design element and our group was in consensus with this. But a benign opening leads to a stunning stretch on the back nine which will demand your attention on the golf course because, trust me, the visual distractions are beautiful. This course placed anywhere from 7 to 9 in our foursomes selections. It was one of the most fun courses we experienced.

8 – Glasgow Hills – This course provided our group the most diverse opinions. Personally, I liked the course. After an impressive and stunning opening nine, and strong and unique design elements on the back, the 17th hole was a challenge to play and understand from a design perspective. And given the quality options we had to choose, this moved this course down on my list. One other playing partner felt similar, placing it at 8. The other two did not enjoy the layout and placed this at 10. I’d gladly play it again and would approach the 17th with knowledge and understanding to better appreciate that stout uphill hole.

7 – Eagles Glenn – Here, the list tightens in terms of group appeal. The differences from this selection to number 3 are subtle and very subjective. For me, I had to reflect back and ask myself if this was properly placed? It is, as while the course lacked any significant shortcoming, it also lacked aspects which would move it up in relation to others. My playing partners disagreed, all placing this course in positions 4 or 5 on the Island. Make no mistake, I’d be proud to be a member at Eagles Glenn and play that course every day.

6 – Fox Meadow – This was ranked low on my initial list (#9). I failed to find any wow factor to this course and it lacked the cache and appeal of others on the Island. Well, let me dispel that. Fox Meadow is a superb championship course. Best practice facilities on the Island, extremely close to Charlottetown and a wonderful design which provides diversity of golf holes and a strong closing stretch. For one playing partner, this was his number 3 course on the Island. I was pleasantly surprised with this course and look forward to a return visit.

010

My favourite picture of Mill River is the par 3, downhill 5th hole. Stunning.

5 – Brudenell River – Clustered in the middle of a group of courses placed #3 – 7, Brudenell River is unique and enjoyable to play. I have posted a review of this course and loved the experience of playing it. I really believe it was one of the strongest layouts, and certainly one of the more walkable courses on the Island. Add the fact it is part of a 36 hole facility with Dundarave and it becomes a must play for travelers.

4 – Mill River – I ranked this 6th in my initial listing in September. After playing this course, it has moved up which is not a surprise to the people who are fortunate to play this course regularly. Set on the western side of the Island it is well worth the drive to go play this course. From the superior service to the immaculate conditioning, this course has it all. From the opening hole, I knew this would be one of my favourites. My playing partners were split on this, with one other placing this higher up on his list; the other two setting it lower on their lists. The range – from 3 to 8 – is the highest of any course we played.

3 – Green Gables – The genius of Stanley Thompson can be seen in Cavendish on this championship course. The course fits the land perfectly, meandering around PEI National Park and making its way past Anne’s house toward the ocean on the back nine. Matt Ginella states that great courses have a combination of fun, wow factor, and prestige. Perhaps the prestige of this course is lost somewhat among the quality of play on the Island and even within Thompson’s vast portfolio but for me this was a real highlight set amongst great courses throughout the Island. If you’re sensing a theme within our foursome you’re correct in that two of us had this very highly ranked and the other two set it lower. For one playing partner, this course was placed 2nd. I can see a case for it.

2 – Dundarave – Set within a listing of great national courses, Dundarave holds a rightful place. This design is the sister course for Brudenell River but location and quality are the only two similarities. Dundarave is more a brute; a demanding championship course with its iconic red clay bunkers. Expansive in layout and immaculate in conditioning it was a clear second ranked course within our group. Three of us four placed this as our number 2 ranked course. It is that good.

1 – Crowbush Cove – to no one’s surprise this course emerged as a consensus number one pick. A worth national top 10 public golf course, the unique location is matched with a dynamic layout and outstanding conditioning. We hadn’t pulled out of the driveway when I started thinking and wondering when I could get back and play this course again. I have drafted a review which will likely be posted on my blog over the holidays.

008

From left to right – Joel, Andrew, Mike and Greg. A beautiful morning as we prepare to tee off at Dundarave.

Well, there you have it, my top 10 list of PEI golf courses. If you have played on the Island, let me know your thoughts. If you’re planning to visit the Island at some point, I highly recommend the PEI Green Card. For $379 plus taxes we were able to play all 10 of these courses. What a great golfing experience.

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “My PEI Course Ranking – After and Before

  1. A lot for golf of such a little island. I am a big fan of Fox Meadows. Stanhope, while lacking some of the hype of the others has some great holes. I am also a big fan of Avondale, which didn’t make your list, but is worth a look.

    • Thanks, Aaron. You have identified another limitation with this list…the Island has more than 10 courses and many, from what I have heard, are wonderful. Some great 9 hole layouts. I’ll add that to my list!
      Thanks, Mike

  2. Great stuff Mike… for the record, here is my Top 10 that we played:

    10. Glasgow Hills
    9. Anderson’s Creek
    8. Stanhope
    7. Mill River
    6. Brudenell
    5. Green Gables
    4. Eagles Glenn
    3. Fox Meadow
    2. Dundarave
    1. Crowbush

    I have been fortunate enough to be playing this amazing game since I was 5 after being introduced to the game by my father and step-father. I’ve had the chance to play some amazing course all over the world and a lot in this great country of ours. This was an amazing, unique experience and I think my shoulders are still recovering from the 180 holes in 6 days!

    All the courses we played had ‘something’ for everyone in our group. I placed Glasgow Hills at the bottom for one simple reason: the back nine was the most infuriating back nine I’ve ever played. Too finish a great front nine with that 17th hole, I was ready to just walk to the car and forget about the 18th. I’ve never been so angry with a hole, and I didn’t play that badly either – it was just that ‘something’ that killed me. It’s like the designer said “here’s where the 16th and 18th is going, let’s just jam a hole in here.’

    Anyway, that being said, I loved the front nine and the course had some of the best vistas anywhere on the island.

    A great trip, and a great wrap up Mike. Looking forward to each review you have planned.

    Cheers,
    Andrew

    • Thanks, Andrew.
      Yes, it was a lot of golf but I miss it. Good point, too, about something for everyone on a golf course…true. The reviews will be scattered throughout the winter. Consider it 10 chances to revisit the trip. It was a great one, Andrew. Hard to see that being topped.
      Cheers, Mike

      • Yes, it’ll be hard to top it… however, playing Cliffs and Links back to back while staying on property next summer, then playing The Lakes and Highlands, just might do it.

        We might have to stop at Beddeck Lobster Suppers too 🙂

  3. Finding this long after it was posted….
    PEI is one of my favourite summer destinations. The golf is excellent and the people even better. Liked your list…..haven’t played a couple….but the one addendum I would place to your order would be….mosquitos!!!!
    You were very fortunate to play Crowbush is a huge wind. When the wind is down….and the dew is on the ground….the Mosquitos are monstrous (and hungry). I’ve played Crowbush and Dundarave a few times each and find Dundarave the better golf course….while Crowbush has the better scenery (and a great 10-12 holes).
    Loved your review of Mill River. It’s been a while since I played it but very happy to hear that it’s still a great track. Way less traffic on Mill River too.

    Thanks for the review. Took me down memory lane. Looking forward to getting back there this summer and giving Fox Meadow a run (after a few at Dundarave!).

    JP

    • Thanks, John
      Playing in October helped, I suspect, where mosquitos are concerned. But even if it was the heart of bug season we would have been ok that day at Crowbush. And you’re spot on, the golf is only exceeded by the people. Half way done my reviews and plan to get another one up within a week or so. Hope you’re able to get back there this summer. Thanks again, Mike

  4. Pingback: Bucket List Overview – Part 4 – Prince Edward Island – 36aday

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s